Phrenic

Guest Judge Comments on:
Phrenic's
Pestilence

6 point(s) for Composition / Songwriting
pretty bogstandard composition for this kind of dance track. while not setting the world alight it is still good quality

6 point(s) for Performance
I think the sounds could have been a little more original.

6 point(s) for Capture
pretty good, but it sounds like early days and I think this producer could do better if pushed.


18 Total Points
good but not original enough. seek different sounds, sounds nobody else has...listen to Calvin harris's album and you'll see what I mean.


eddytemple-morris
Sun Dec 27 01:11:59 2009

Guest Judge Comments on:
Phrenic's
Pestilence

5 point(s) for Composition / Songwriting
A GREAT 2AM FLOOR FILLER, NICE, DARK, DIRTY AND A BIT SINISTER.
I'M A LITTLE WORRIED IT SOUNDS A TOUCH DATED, THIS KINDA TRIBAL STYLE HAS BEEN KNOCKING AROUND FOR A FEW YEARS NOW, BUT IT'S STILL GETTING PLAYED IN CLUBS ACROSS THE UK, SO FAIR PLAY!! VERY HIGH QUALITY & COULD BE PLAYED ALONG WITH A LEE COOMBS TRACK EASY.



6 point(s) for Performance
I WAS WAITING FOR THE TRACK TO GO SOMEWHERE THEN REMEMBERED THESE TRACKS DON’T AND SHOULDN’T.

7 point(s) for Capture
THE SOUNDS ARE A BIT OLD HAT, THAT CONGA LOOPS BEEN AROUND SINCE YEAR DOT! THE BREAKDOWN WAS A BIT SHORT & THE TRACK NEVER REALLY KICKED BACK IN. BUT OVERALL THE TUNE WAS RECORDED & MIXED TO A VERY HIGH STANDARD AND SOUNDED GREAT CRANKED UP, TOP WORK FELLAS.


18 Total Points
I DO LOVE THESE TYPE OF RECORDS & ARE GLAD PEOPLE ARE STILL MAKING THEM.


jamesatkin
Sun Dec 27 01:12:01 2009

Guest Judge Comments on:
Phrenic's
Pestilence

5 point(s) for Composition / Songwriting
follows the formulae of all techno tracks, unfortunately without throwing up sufficient surprises.

6 point(s) for Performance
the riffs are generic but alright,

6 point(s) for Capture
not really my bag this, but well put together.


17 Total Points
overall the mix could be brighter and more expansive, more room


slyde
Sun Dec 27 01:12:04 2009